2024 WVS Research Study View

Name: Apoorva

Organization: Bhandari

Mobile Phone: 4168952486

Email: apoorva.bhandari@lhsc.on.ca

 

Research Topic: Sex and Gender Disparities in Critical Limb Ischemia Management

Background:

CLI represents the most severe manifestation of peripheral arterial disease, characterized by rest pain, ischemic ulcers, and gangrene, underscoring the consequences of impaired limb perfusion. Effective management of CLI requires a comprehensive approach, including guideline-directed medical therapy, revascularization to improve limb perfusion, and meticulous wound care.

The landmark ‘BEST-CLI’ study demonstrated the superiority of bypass surgery over initial endovascular intervention for CLI patients with a suitable single segment great saphenous vein conduit, significantly reducing major adverse limb events (MALEs) and mortality. However, gender-specific differences in CLI management are increasingly recognized, with females often experiencing delayed clinical recognition and evident disparities in treatment outcomes. Given the predominance of male-centric evidence in existing CLI guidelines, there is an urgent need for gender-specific investigations to inform tailored interventions and address these disparities effectively.

Our study aims to evaluate adherence to BEST-CLI1 recommendations in critical limb ischemia management (CLI), with a focus on sex and gender disparities. Despite the comprehensive nature of CLI management, sex- and gender-specific differences in treatment outcomes are often overlooked. We propose a retrospective single-centre cohort study, examining compliance with BEST-CLI recommendations, stratified by sex and gender, and the impact of compliance on patient outcomes, limb salvage, and reintervention.

Specific aims and objectives with project timeline:

Research Question and Objectives:
This study seeks to address the question: How does compliance with BEST-CLI recommendations for CLI management impact patient outcomes, limb salvage, and reintervention when stratified by sex and gender?

Our study aims to evaluate adherence to BEST-CLI recommendations in CLI management stratified by sex and gender at the London Health Science Center (LHSC), a high-volume institution, over the past five years. We seek to explore how compliance with these recommendations, when stratified by sex and gender, correlate with patient outcomes, limb salvage, and reintervention. Additionally, this study aims to identify sex- and gender-specific differences in treatment approaches and outcomes, aiming to bridge existing knowledge gaps related to sex and gender disparities. Finally, this study intends to provide valuable insights that can inform intervention guidelines that assure all CLI patients are treated optimally, irrespective of sex and gender.
Our primary outcome will be compliance rates with BEST-CLI practices stratified by sex and gender. Our secondary outcome will be the impact of compliance on patient outcomes, limb salvage, and reintervention, also stratified by sex and gender.

This study uniquely examines sex and gender differences in CLI treatment and outcomes, addressing gender disparities in vascular research. Illuminating how different sexes and genders experience CLI differently promotes inclusivity within vascular surgery and aims to address the knowledge gap regarding sex and gender disparities in CLI management, specifically in adherence to BEST-CLI recommendations. Ultimately, this study aims to offer valuable insights to inform intervention guidelines, ensuring optimal treatment for all CLI patients regardless of sex and gender.

Project Timeline:
We are currently in the process of submitting our study for LHSC Research Ethics Board (REB) approval and anticipate completion of this process by end of May 2024, with plans to start data extraction in June 2024. We estimate data collection and analysis will take approximately 6-9 months (June 2024-February 2025). Manuscript drafting will start concurrently with data analysis and is estimated to take around 2-3 months (June 2024-May 2025), with estimated manuscript submission by end of May 2025.

 

How the money would be spent:

The project costs encompass two main categories: personnel and software expenses. Personnel costs involve research assistant fees, totalling $10,000, and securing a statistical expertise for $2,000, resulting in a combined expenditure of $12,000. Software fees comprise the acquisition of the REDCap Data Management software, amounting to $5,000. Therefore, the overall budget for the project stands at $17,000.

Name: Katherine Kerr

Organization: University of Pittsburgh

Mobile Phone: 7244628423

Email: kak488@pitt.edu

 

Research Topic: Investigating sex-based differences in AAA using biomechanics and sex-specific machine learning models to predict patient outcomes

Background:

Abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is a localized dilation of the infrarenal aorta that can be devastating when ruptured, with literature reporting a mortality rate of up to 90%*. The current metric used for repairing AAA is the maximum diameter criterion, where surgical repair is recommended for AAAs with diameters over 5.0 cm for women and 5.5 cm for men. However, literature has reported that over 10% of female patients’ aneurysms rupture below the clinical threshold of 5.0 cm*. Additionally, women experience higher mortality and more postoperative complications from AAA than men*. Although the prevalence of AAA is greater among males, small AAAs rupture at a rate three to four times higher in women than men*. Considering that female patients rupture at higher rates and have worse clinical outcomes than males*, it is important to find a more accurate criterion for prediction of AAA rupture risk. Despite this evidence and the fact that AAA rupture represents the biomechanical failure of the aortic wall, the cause of these sex-based differences in AAA are not well studied from a biomechanical perspective. Machine learning (ML) has shown promise for predicting rupture risk, but sex-based differences have not yet been accounted for in such models.

Specific aims and objectives with project timeline:

Specific Aim 1: Create image-based biomechanical and morphological parameters for improved prediction in female patients. Maximum diameter normalized to body surface area has been shown to be a more accurate indicator of patient outcome compared to diameter alone*. However, these studies did not investigate biomechanical or morphological parameters. This aim will test the hypothesis that an arrangement of biomechanical, morphological, and clinical parameters will result in a higher sensitivity and specificity in sex-dependent ML models than solely relying on the maximum diameter criterion. Using a high-throughput analysis approach, this work proposes to perform the largest biomechanical and morphological analysis of female AAA patients to date. In addition to available clinical variables, biomechanical and morphological parameters will be extracted using well-established methods for over 2200 computed tomography image sets, including over 600 female patients. These metrics will then be indexed to patient-specific maximum diameter. Cutoff points for each metric as well as indexed metrics will be created by calculating the inflection point where percentage of aneurysms ruptured increases sharply. These new cutoffs will be evaluated for sensitivity and specificity. Through this aim, we expect to find morphological and biomechanical parameters that better predict patient outcomes than the current criterion of maximum diameter.
Specific Aim 2: Train and evaluate sex-dependent ML models. ML models trained by our lab have previously shown promise in predicting patient outcomes, but these models do not include any sex-specific parameters. In this aim, we propose creating sex-dependent ML models and evaluating sensitivity and specificity of these models to determine if they improve predictions for male and female patients. Sex-specific ML models for informing AAA rupture risk will be trained using parameters showing strong predictive potential and compared to a previously trained ML model that did not account for sex-specific metrics. Successful execution of this aim will provide improved sex-specific ML models to develop new, clinically useful AAA thresholds.
Innovation: Female AAA patients have been understudied in the field of biomechanics. Far fewer female patients than male patients have undergone modern CT-based biomechanical analysis, with the largest study in the literature having a cohort of 45 women*. The combination of novel investigation into sex-based biomechanical and morphological parameters for AAA prediction and sex-dependent ML models provide an opportunity for improved prediction of AAA in a previously understudied group. Combined, this proposal would expand current knowledge of sex-based differences in AAA biomechanics, which would work towards improving outcomes for female patients.
Timeline: This project would take place over the course of a calendar year. A portion of the dataset has already been processed and analyzed, but over 80% of the dataset still needs to be processed and undergo biomechanical analyses, which will be allocated 2 months. Aim 1, which consists of normalizing parameters and analyzing the sensitivity and specificity of each in predicting outcome, will take about 4 months to complete and Aim 2, which will include training these sex-dependent models and retraining a previously trained model will take about 6 months to complete.
*References available upon request

 

How the money would be spent:

This project is a collaboration between the University of Pittsburgh and Mayo Clinic with principal investigators Dr. Timothy Chung, PhD and Dr. Indrani Sen, MBBS. Dr. Sen is a vascular surgeon and Dr. Chung has expertise in AAA biomechanics and machine learning. The funds allocated for this work would provide for improved computational capabilities as well as travel grants and submission costs to share this work. On the computational front, these funds would be used to purchase computer parts, such as a graphics processing unit which is an important piece of technology for machine learning computations, cloud computing space, and cloud storage. We estimate $3000 would be spent on computer parts and cloud computing space and storage. These computer parts would allow us to process our data sets more efficiently and expediate the analysis and model training process. In addition to computing equipment, the funds would be used to communicate our work. As mentioned at the Women’s Vascular Summit this year, an issue vascular surgery faces is the lack of publications and research surrounding women’s AAA outcomes. This funding would provide funds to cover the costs of a graduate student publishing her work on this topic. We will allocate $1500 to publishing fees. Additionally, being able to present our findings at conferences is crucial for collaboration and feedback. The remaining section of this funding, $500, would be allocated for our graduate student to register at conferences and attend to present her work.

Name: Nabeeha Khan

Organization: Loyola University Medical Center

Mobile Phone: 2244258351

Email: nkhan18@luc.edu

 

Research Topic: Referral Source and its Influence on Outcomes in Patients with Chronic Limb-Threatening Ischemia

Background:

Peripheral artery disease (PAD) refers to stenosis or occlusion of lower extremity arteries. Symptoms range from asymptomatic to demand ischemia (claudication) to the most severe, chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI), marked by prolonged (> two weeks) ischemic rest pain, non-healing wounds/ulcers, or gangrene. CLTI leads to substantial morbidity, including limb loss, reduced quality of life, and increased mortality. CLTI causes significant morbidity with limb loss, rest pain, decreased health-related quality of life; and mortality.

Women with CLTI typically manifest with different symptoms, often starting asymptomatically but experiencing rapid functional decline. They tend to present with advanced disease during revascularization, potentially leading to poorer outcomes, although gender’s precise impact remains ambiguous due to underrepresentation in studies.

The growing prevalence of CLTI risk factors underscores the importance of preventive measures. Timely detection and intervention are crucial, as delays in revascularization correlate with higher mortality and limb loss. However, the influence of referring physician specialty on outcomes post-revascularization remains inadequately studied.

Managing CLTI requires a multidisciplinary approach involving medical therapy, pain management, wound care, and surgical interventions. Collaboration among various healthcare providers, including vascular surgeons, is essential for optimal patient care.

Specific aims and objectives with project timeline:

This study aims to investigate whether the specialty of the referring physician (podiatry, cardiology, primary care, etc.) influences outcomes in patients with CLTI, focusing on 1-year amputation-free survival, wound healing, and the necessity for revascularization. Additionally, we seek to understand if prior medical management by these specialties impacts CLTI outcomes upon evaluation by vascular surgeons. Furthermore, we aim to examine gender-based differences in referral patterns and outcomes post-revascularization.

The project timeline is as follows:
1. Data Collection and Cohort Identification (Months 1-3):

a. Retrospective review of patients treated for CLTI at the Division of Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy at Loyola Medicine from 2017-2022.

b. Classification of patients into two cohorts: referred or emergent.

c. Further division of the referred cohort by referring specialty.

2. Multivariable Analysis and Data Interpretation (Month 4-5):

a. Conducting multivariable analysis utilizing significant univariable features (baseline demographics, co-morbidities, medications at the time of referral, etc.) associated with adverse outcomes.

b. Accounting for any disproportionate adverse baseline characteristics in patient cohorts.

c. Evaluation of outcomes, including one-year amputation-free survival, wound healing, and the need for revascularization, among different referring specialties.

d. Analysis of the impact of prior medical management by various specialties on CLTI outcomes post-referral to vascular surgeons.

e. Assessment of gender-based differences in referral patterns and outcomes post-revascularization.

3. Data Reporting: Abstract Submission, Presentation (Month 6-7)

4. Data Publication: Manuscript Submission

This study utilizes a retrospective review methodology, drawing data from a specific time frame and patient cohort. Through comprehensive analysis, this study has the potential to identify opportunities for earlier recognition of PAD in the outpatient setting. It also could change inherent screening biases based on patient demographics (i.e.., race and gender differences) and time to referral to a surgical service. This may, ultimately, facilitate more rapid initiation of best medical therapy and, as needed, procedural intervention to minimize limb loss and mortality.

 

How the money would be spent:

A significant portion of the retrospective chart review research grant would be designated to provide statistical support, ensuring timely data analysis and interpretation. Funds would be allocated to acquire access to advanced statistical software packages and hire skilled statisticians to conduct in-depth analyses of the collected data. Additionally, resources would cover publication costs, including fees associated with submitting research findings to peer-reviewed journals or open-access publications. Moreover, the grant would include coverage for conference travel, enabling us to present our findings at relevant scientific conferences, participate in discussions, and network within the community. This exposure not only enhances the visibility and impact of the research, but also facilitates knowledge exchange and collaboration within the academic community.